I vote for the original (steampunk version). New one looks too cartoon-ish.
I love both of them, except the bright cartoony colours. However, let's combine them!
Doormaster's version, but Raddigans final steampunk colour scheme. Perhaps a yellowish tint for the duck bill.
I know it's easy for me to say this when I'm not the ones actually making this stuff though! But still, awesome work guys.